{
  "repo": {
    "slug": "NeuruhAI/lead-recipe-os",
    "head": "7363dcb1efab4dad3e44c7408ba921b193304ff7",
    "fetched": "2026-11-20",
    "method": "git clone --depth 1, read-only; fresh fetch 2026-11-20 confirmed the same HEAD and byte-identical graph.py, contracts.py, compose.py, validate.py and recipes_canonical.py vs the vendor tree"
  },
  "as_of": "2026-11-20",
  "registry": {
    "recipes": 558,
    "signals": 317,
    "ingredients": 107,
    "sources": 154,
    "territories": 3293,
    "canonical_library": 58,
    "curated_library": 500
  },
  "fragment_inventory": {
    "ops_in_registry_membership_logic": {
      "ABSENT": 10,
      "ADJACENT": 9,
      "ALL": 557,
      "ANY": 26,
      "LEAF": 1167,
      "NEAR": 1,
      "NOT": 13,
      "RECURRENCE": 10,
      "SEQUENCE": 19,
      "WITHIN_DAYS": 20
    },
    "defeater_recipes": [
      {
        "recipe_id": "tax_pressure_equity",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "listing.active",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[2]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "open_probate_property",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "probate.closed",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[1]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          },
          {
            "signal": "deed.recorded_event",
            "decisive": false,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[2]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "pre_probate_verified_death_event_property",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "probate.opened",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[1]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "estate_tax_pressure",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "probate.closed",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[2]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "heir_curative",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "deed.recorded_event",
            "decisive": false,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[1]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "failed_listing_high_equity_long_tenure",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "listing.active",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[3]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "recipe_id": "long_hold_free_clear",
        "library": "canonical",
        "defeater_clauses": [
          {
            "signal": "listing.active",
            "decisive": true,
            "defeater": true,
            "state": "PRESENT",
            "cmp": null,
            "context": [
              "ALL[2]",
              "NOT[0]"
            ]
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "recipes_with_defeater_clause": 7,
    "defeater_clauses_total": 8,
    "defeater_clause_signals": [
      "deed.recorded_event",
      "listing.active",
      "probate.closed",
      "probate.opened"
    ],
    "defeater_clauses_decisive_and_defeater": 6,
    "defeater_clauses_defeater_only": 2,
    "defeater_clauses_in_qualifying_logic": 0,
    "signals_by_source_state": {
      "AVAILABLE": 29,
      "MISSING": 34,
      "PARTIAL": 174,
      "PROPOSED": 54,
      "SOURCE_REQUIRED": 17,
      "WALLED": 9
    },
    "source_blocked_signals": 114,
    "source_feasible_signals": 203,
    "composer_grammar_ops": [
      "ALL",
      "ANY",
      "NOT",
      "ABSENT",
      "WITHIN_DAYS",
      "SEQUENCE",
      "RECURRENCE",
      "NEAR",
      "ADJACENT"
    ],
    "fragment_definition": "FULL-COMP: composer grammar ops, flat ALL at top, any leaf clause may carry defeater=True and/or decisive=True; composer never emits defeater, so defeater trees are hand-built by compose plus signal_logic swap, then validated",
    "registry_defeater_rows_evaluated": {
      "listing.active": {
        "tax_pressure_equity": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        },
        "failed_listing_high_equity_long_tenure": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        },
        "long_hold_free_clear": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        }
      },
      "probate.closed": {
        "open_probate_property": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        },
        "estate_tax_pressure": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        }
      },
      "deed.recorded_event": {
        "open_probate_property": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        },
        "heir_curative": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        }
      },
      "probate.opened": {
        "pre_probate_verified_death_event_property": {
          "present": "CONTRADICTED",
          "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
          "empty": "SATISFIED"
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "composer_probe": {
    "random_compose_requests": 100,
    "compose_failures": 1,
    "built_recipes_with_defeater": 0,
    "note": "compose plus build() has no defeater input: negatives are NOT(plain leaf); defeater trees must be hand-built"
  },
  "defeater_hinge": {
    "defeater:ownership.government": {
      "loose": {
        "empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "CONTRADICTED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "SATISFIED",
        "withdrawn": "SATISFIED",
        "superseded": "SATISFIED"
      },
      "default": {
        "empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "SATISFIED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "SATISFIED",
        "withdrawn": "SATISFIED",
        "superseded": "SATISFIED"
      }
    },
    "defeater:listing.active": {
      "loose": {
        "empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "CONTRADICTED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "SATISFIED",
        "withdrawn": "SATISFIED",
        "superseded": "SATISFIED"
      },
      "default": {
        "empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "SATISFIED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "SATISFIED",
        "withdrawn": "SATISFIED",
        "superseded": "SATISFIED"
      }
    },
    "plain:ownership.government": {
      "loose": {
        "empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "CONTRADICTED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "UNKNOWN",
        "withdrawn": "UNKNOWN",
        "superseded": "UNKNOWN"
      },
      "default": {
        "empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "UNKNOWN",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "UNKNOWN",
        "withdrawn": "UNKNOWN",
        "superseded": "UNKNOWN"
      }
    },
    "plain:listing.active": {
      "loose": {
        "empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "CONTRADICTED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "UNKNOWN",
        "withdrawn": "UNKNOWN",
        "superseded": "UNKNOWN"
      },
      "default": {
        "empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "present": "CONTRADICTED",
        "present_lowfloor": "UNKNOWN",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "conflicted": "UNKNOWN",
        "withdrawn": "UNKNOWN",
        "superseded": "UNKNOWN"
      }
    },
    "typed_cmp_defeater:transfer.tenure_years": {
      "loose": {
        "value_20": "CONTRADICTED",
        "value_5": "SATISFIED",
        "evidential_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "empty": "SATISFIED"
      }
    }
  },
  "dichotomy": {
    "timelines": 14,
    "signals_per_timeline": 317,
    "floor_settings": [
      "loose",
      "default"
    ],
    "checks": 8876,
    "violations": [],
    "seconds": 2.02,
    "statement": "for every signal s and every timeline, exactly one of leaf(s, PRESENT) and NOT(leaf(s, PRESENT, defeater=True)) is SATISFIED, at fixed evidence floors"
  },
  "greedy": {
    "empty": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 951,
      "by_kind": {
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317
      },
      "seconds": 1.0814,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 951,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_DEF",
        "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "NOT_DEF",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "empty_with_relations": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3174,
      "n_satisfied": 953,
      "by_kind": {
        "NEAR": 2,
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.4788,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 951,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_DEF",
        "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "NEAR",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "evidence_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_eaf3e5ad"
          },
          {
            "kind": "NEAR",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "evidence_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_e3d3559c"
          },
          {
            "kind": "NOT_DEF",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "full_evidence": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3867,
      "n_satisfied": 1965,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 317,
        "PL_default": 317,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 317,
        "SEQUENCE": 380,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317,
        "DEC_PL": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.9744,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 634,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 0,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7b05f790",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7b05f790"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "random_p0.5": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3709,
      "n_satisfied": 1649,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 159,
        "PL_default": 159,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 159,
        "SEQUENCE": 380,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317,
        "DEC_PL": 159,
        "NOT_DEF": 158,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 158
      },
      "seconds": 1.3353,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 792,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 190,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7b05f790",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7b05f790"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "mixed": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3273,
      "n_satisfied": 1068,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 10,
        "PL_default": 8,
        "AL_loose": 2,
        "AL_default": 2,
        "NOT_PL": 2,
        "ABSENT_op": 2,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 10,
        "RECURRENCE": 3,
        "SEQUENCE": 90,
        "NOT_DEF": 307,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 307,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 315,
        "DEC_PL": 10
      },
      "seconds": 0.8193,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 939,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 394,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_241402ec",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7cc71d72"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_3b812d52"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "schema"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_88e5a1c5"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_241402ec"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "mixed_with_relations": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3277,
      "n_satisfied": 1070,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 10,
        "PL_default": 8,
        "AL_loose": 2,
        "AL_default": 2,
        "NOT_PL": 2,
        "ABSENT_op": 2,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 10,
        "RECURRENCE": 3,
        "SEQUENCE": 90,
        "NEAR": 2,
        "NOT_DEF": 307,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 307,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 315,
        "DEC_PL": 10
      },
      "seconds": 0.7894,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 939,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 394,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_241402ec",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_7cc71d72"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_3b812d52"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "schema"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_88e5a1c5"
          },
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_241402ec"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "single_present": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3171,
      "n_satisfied": 953,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 1,
        "PL_default": 1,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 1,
        "NOT_DEF": 316,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 316,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317,
        "DEC_PL": 1
      },
      "seconds": 0.9145,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 950,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 404,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_f48c9f58",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_f48c9f58"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "absent_only": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 957,
      "by_kind": {
        "AL_loose": 2,
        "AL_default": 2,
        "NOT_PL": 2,
        "ABSENT_op": 2,
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 315
      },
      "seconds": 0.8197,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 949,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_PL",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_c4b8118e",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "AL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_33d2b9e2"
          },
          {
            "kind": "AL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "contradiction_detection"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_68610624"
          },
          {
            "kind": "AL_loose",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_33d2b9e2"
          },
          {
            "kind": "AL_loose",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "contradiction_detection"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_68610624"
          },
          {
            "kind": "NOT_PL",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": false,
            "validate_passed": false,
            "failed_checks": [
              "source_feasibility"
            ],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_caff8326"
          },
          {
            "kind": "NOT_PL",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_c4b8118e"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "lowfloor_only": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3174,
      "n_satisfied": 955,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 2,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 2,
        "SEQUENCE": 2,
        "NOT_DEF": 315,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 315,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317,
        "DEC_PL": 2
      },
      "seconds": 0.5785,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 949,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 402,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_loose",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_1f85dad7",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_loose",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_1f85dad7"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "withdrawn_only_small": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 951,
      "by_kind": {
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.8116,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 951,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_DEF",
        "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "NOT_DEF",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "withdrawn_full": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 951,
      "by_kind": {
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.6872,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 951,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_DEF",
        "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "NOT_DEF",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "conflicted_full": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 951,
      "by_kind": {
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.33,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 951,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "NOT_DEF",
        "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "NOT_DEF",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_defeater_witness_26e02efb"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "all_absent_full": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3170,
      "n_satisfied": 1902,
      "by_kind": {
        "AL_loose": 317,
        "AL_default": 317,
        "NOT_PL": 317,
        "ABSENT_op": 317,
        "NOT_DEF": 317,
        "NOT_DEF_DEC": 317
      },
      "seconds": 1.8195,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 634,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 406,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "AL_default",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_9b44c8d5",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "AL_default",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_9b44c8d5"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "all_present_lowfloor_full": {
      "found_nodes": true,
      "n_candidates": 3867,
      "n_satisfied": 1648,
      "by_kind": {
        "PL_loose": 317,
        "WITHIN_DAYS": 317,
        "SEQUENCE": 380,
        "NOT_DEF_ABS": 317,
        "DEC_PL": 317
      },
      "seconds": 0.3955,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_nodes": 634,
      "n_satisfied_defeater_source_feasible": 0,
      "decision_valid_recipe_exists": true,
      "witness": {
        "built": true,
        "kind": "PL_loose",
        "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_d350878f",
        "attempts": [
          {
            "kind": "PL_loose",
            "stage": "validate+evaluate",
            "ok": true,
            "validate_passed": true,
            "failed_checks": [],
            "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
            "recipe_id": "gen_greedy_witness_d350878f"
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  },
  "brute_force_agreement": {
    "vocabulary_size": 8,
    "full_fragment": {
      "trials": 47,
      "agree": 47,
      "disagree": [],
      "all_yes": true,
      "seconds": 3.6
    },
    "defeater_free_replication": {
      "trials": 44,
      "agree": 44,
      "disagree": []
    },
    "tree_sizes_enumerated": "ALL over subsets of size 1..3 from the per-signal node pool (plain/ABSENT/NOT/ABSENT-op/WITHIN/RECURRENCE/SEQUENCE forms, plus NOT_DEF, NOT_DEF_DEC, DEC_PL in the full run)",
    "note": "the full-fragment agreement is YES-dominated by design: the dichotomy guarantees a SATISFIED node on every timeline, so both sides answer YES; the substantive checks are the dichotomy itself and the validity-aware witness construction"
  },
  "edge_case_no_logic": {
    "compose_empty_logic": "compose refused: 1 validation error for RecipeDef\n  Value error, gen_empty_edge_f19a53cb: a recipe needs signal_logic or required_signals [type=value_error, input_value={'recipe",
    "no_logic_with_required_signal": {
      "validate_passed": true,
      "failed_checks": [],
      "eval_outcome_on_empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
      "eval_outcome_on_full_timeline": "SATISFIED"
    },
    "note": "a None-logic row is a META recipe, not a composer tree, and is excluded from FULL-COMP by definition; the check shows whether the exclusion matters"
  },
  "three_sat_attempt": {
    "variables": [
      "tax.delinquent",
      "probate.opened",
      "listing.active"
    ],
    "assignment_alpha": {
      "tax.delinquent": true,
      "probate.opened": true,
      "listing.active": false
    },
    "strategy_C_defeater_negation_formula_in_tree": {
      "phi_sat": {
        "formula_tree_on_alpha_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "formula_tree_decisive_on_alpha_timeline": "SATISFIED",
        "formula_tree_on_empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN"
      },
      "phi_unsat": {
        "formula_tree_on_alpha_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "formula_tree_decisive_on_alpha_timeline": "UNKNOWN",
        "formula_tree_on_empty_timeline": "UNKNOWN"
      },
      "phi_all_negative_on_empty_timeline": "SATISFIED",
      "phi_all_negative_on_alpha_timeline": "SATISFIED",
      "greedy_nodes_on_alpha_timeline": true,
      "trivial_nodes_on_alpha_timeline": {
        "leaf_x1_present": "SATISFIED",
        "not_defeater_x3_absent": "SATISFIED",
        "not_defeater_x1_present": "CONTRADICTED"
      },
      "verdict": "the formula tree itself now distinguishes SAT from UNSAT on a fixed assignment timeline (SATISFIED vs UNKNOWN); the decisive variant does not change this, because _combine_any drops decisiveness, so the outer ALL still sees a non-decisive contradiction and returns UNKNOWN; and a negative literal is true by default on the empty timeline, so the all-negative clause is SATISFIED with no assignment at all; but the decision is existential over trees, and the timeline always offers a trivial SATISFIED node, so UNSAT still answers YES"
    },
    "strategy_D_formula_in_timeline_assignment_in_tree": {
      "phi_sat": {
        "clause_slots_present": 2,
        "reference_assignment_tree_alpha0": "SATISFIED",
        "satisfying_assignment_tree_alpha": "UNKNOWN",
        "greedy_nodes": true
      },
      "phi_unsat": {
        "clause_slots_present": 8,
        "reference_assignment_tree_alpha0": "SATISFIED",
        "satisfying_assignment_tree_alpha": "UNKNOWN",
        "greedy_nodes": true
      },
      "slot_reading": {
        "leaf_clause_slot_present": "SATISFIED",
        "leaf_clause_slot_absent": "UNKNOWN"
      },
      "verdict": "the tree is checked against the timeline's fixed reference assignment, never against the formula: the reference assignment tree is SATISFIED for both phi_sat and phi_unsat, and a genuinely satisfying assignment tree is UNKNOWN because it disagrees with the reference; the clause slots are read only as 'present or not', which carries no clause semantics, and the tree may omit them entirely"
    },
    "strategy_E_formula_in_validity": {
      "satisfying_assignment_tree_alpha": {
        "stage": "validate+evaluate",
        "validate_passed": true,
        "failed_checks": [
          "source_feasibility"
        ],
        "eval_outcome": "UNKNOWN",
        "recipe_id": "gen_validity_probe_57994e6c"
      },
      "nonsatisfying_assignment_tree_beta": {
        "stage": "validate+evaluate",
        "validate_passed": true,
        "failed_checks": [
          "source_feasibility"
        ],
        "eval_outcome": "UNKNOWN",
        "recipe_id": "gen_validity_probe_57994e6c"
      },
      "formula_tree_phi_sat": {
        "stage": "validate+evaluate",
        "validate_passed": true,
        "failed_checks": [
          "source_feasibility"
        ],
        "eval_outcome": "SATISFIED",
        "recipe_id": "gen_validity_probe_57994e6c"
      },
      "formula_tree_phi_unsat": {
        "stage": "validate+evaluate",
        "validate_passed": true,
        "failed_checks": [
          "source_feasibility"
        ],
        "eval_outcome": "UNKNOWN",
        "recipe_id": "gen_validity_probe_57994e6c"
      },
      "verdict": "validate() takes no timeline and reads no formula: a satisfying assignment tree, a non-satisfying assignment tree, and the two formula trees all validate or fail identically on the same request shape, so the validity layer cannot gate on satisfiability either"
    },
    "verdict": "all three encodings fail the equivalence, for three different structural reasons: C fails because the search is existential over trees and a trivial SATISFIED node always exists; D fails because the tree is checked against the timeline's fixed reference assignment and the clause slots carry no clause semantics; E fails because validate() takes no timeline and reads no formula"
  },
  "cost": {
    "greedy_candidates_full_vocab": 3867,
    "defeater_candidates_full_vocab": 1268,
    "seconds_per_node_eval": 0.000542,
    "greedy_seconds_full_evidence": 0.9744,
    "greedy_seconds_empty_timeline": 1.0814,
    "greedy_seconds_withdrawn_full": 0.6872,
    "exhaustive_1node_seconds_est": 2.09,
    "exhaustive_2node_seconds_est": 4049.3,
    "exhaustive_3node_seconds_est": 5216819.6,
    "note": "exhaustive 2-node and 3-node estimates are extrapolations from the measured per-evaluation cost; the greedy decision needs one pass over the node pool only, plus a bounded number of validate() calls whose results are timeline-independent and cached"
  },
  "total_seconds": 30.51,
  "verdict": "Constructive direction SUCCEEDS for the FULL fragment with defeaters, and the defeater rule makes the decision easier, not harder: for every signal and every timeline exactly one of leaf(s) and NOT(defeater leaf(s)) is SATISFIED, so a SATISFIED node always exists and node-wise greedy search decides FULL-COMP in polynomial time, with real witnesses built through compose plus signal_logic swap and validated. Hardness direction FAILS on all three defeater encodings: the formula tree can distinguish SAT from UNSAT on a fixed assignment, but the search never has to use it. Nothing here separates or collapses P and NP, and none is claimed."
}