{
  "repo": {
    "slug": "NeuruhAI/lead-recipe-os",
    "head": "7363dcb1efab4dad3e44c7408ba921b193304ff7",
    "fetched": "2026-11-20",
    "method": "git clone --depth 1, read-only"
  },
  "as_of": "2026-11-20",
  "round": 5,
  "angle": "(b) wider fragment: arbitrary defeater-free LogicNode trees over all 15 LOGIC_OPS, plus the validity-aware triple-rescue test; the two gaps named in data/p_vs_np_greedy_proof_r4.md section 5",
  "registry": {
    "recipes": 558,
    "signals": 317,
    "ingredients": 107,
    "sources": 154,
    "territories": 3293
  },
  "op_inventory": {
    "ops_in_registry_membership_logic": {
      "ABSENT": 10,
      "ADJACENT": 9,
      "ALL": 557,
      "ANY": 26,
      "LEAF": 1167,
      "NEAR": 1,
      "NOT": 13,
      "RECURRENCE": 10,
      "SEQUENCE": 19,
      "WITHIN_DAYS": 20
    },
    "ops_in_registry_but_not_in_composer_grammar": [],
    "six_non_composer_ops_present_in_registry": [],
    "note": "the six ops exist in LOGIC_OPS and evaluate_logic but are emitted by no recipe in the registry and by no composer request; they are reachable only in hand-built trees"
  },
  "reduction_check": {
    "per_op": {
      "COUNT_AT_LEAST_2": {
        "nodes_tested": 280,
        "satisfied": 74,
        "reduction_holds": 74,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      },
      "CONVERGENCE": {
        "nodes_tested": 280,
        "satisfied": 74,
        "reduction_holds": 74,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      },
      "COUNT_AT_LEAST_3": {
        "nodes_tested": 560,
        "satisfied": 127,
        "reduction_holds": 127,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      },
      "CONTRADICTION_FREE_0": {
        "nodes_tested": 10,
        "satisfied": 10,
        "reduction_holds": 0,
        "reduction_violations": 10
      },
      "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1": {
        "nodes_tested": 3170,
        "satisfied": 3168,
        "reduction_holds": 504,
        "reduction_violations": 2664
      },
      "CHANGE": {
        "nodes_tested": 11,
        "satisfied": 1,
        "reduction_holds": 1,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      },
      "ACCELERATION": {
        "nodes_tested": 11,
        "satisfied": 6,
        "reduction_holds": 6,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      },
      "PERSISTENCE": {
        "nodes_tested": 11,
        "satisfied": 1,
        "reduction_holds": 1,
        "reduction_violations": 0
      }
    },
    "violations": [
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_0",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CONTRADICTION_FREE_1",
        "timeline": "empty",
        "note": "SATISFIED with no SATISFIED plain leaf witness"
      }
    ],
    "seconds": 1.13,
    "note": "reduction = every SATISFIED extra-op node implies SATISFIED plain loose leaves already in the greedy pool; CONTRADICTION_FREE is the only op that violates it"
  },
  "brute_force_agreement_extended": {
    "without_contradiction_free": {
      "trials": 44,
      "agree": 44,
      "disagree": [],
      "pool_size_min": 144,
      "pool_size_max": 163,
      "seconds": 174.67,
      "tree_sizes_enumerated": "ALL over subsets of size 1..3 from the extended per-signal pool (r2 forms plus CHANGE, ACCELERATION, PERSISTENCE, COUNT_AT_LEAST_2/3, CONVERGENCE)"
    },
    "with_contradiction_free": {
      "trials": 44,
      "agree": 44,
      "disagree": [],
      "pool_size_min": 153,
      "pool_size_max": 172,
      "seconds": 1.32,
      "tree_sizes_enumerated": "ALL over subsets of size 1..3 from the extended per-signal pool (r2 forms plus CHANGE, ACCELERATION, PERSISTENCE, COUNT_AT_LEAST_2/3, CONVERGENCE, CONTRADICTION_FREE_0/1)"
    }
  },
  "triple_validity": {
    "all_present_8": {
      "n_satisfied_leaves": 16,
      "signals_with_satisfied_leaf": [
        "code.violation",
        "death.verified",
        "deed.recorded_event",
        "heirship.unresolved",
        "listing.active",
        "ownership.government",
        "probate.opened",
        "tax.delinquent"
      ],
      "rows": {
        "size_1": {
          "tried": 16,
          "valid": 8,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 6,
            "contradiction_detection": 2
          },
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation"
            ],
            [
              "PL_default:code.violation"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:heirship.unresolved"
            ]
          ]
        },
        "size_2": {
          "tried": 112,
          "valid": 72,
          "failed_checks": {
            "contradiction_detection": 28,
            "source_feasibility": 24
          },
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "PL_loose:death.verified"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "PL_default:death.verified"
            ],
            [
              "PL_default:code.violation",
              "PL_loose:death.verified"
            ]
          ]
        },
        "size_3": {
          "tried": 448,
          "valid": 272,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 128,
            "contradiction_detection": 168
          },
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "PL_loose:death.verified",
              "PL_loose:deed.recorded_event"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "PL_loose:death.verified",
              "PL_default:deed.recorded_event"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "PL_default:death.verified",
              "PL_loose:deed.recorded_event"
            ]
          ]
        }
      },
      "triple_rescue": {
        "found": false,
        "triple": null
      }
    },
    "mixed_8": {
      "n_satisfied_leaves": 15,
      "signals_with_satisfied_leaf": [
        "code.violation",
        "deed.recorded_event",
        "heirship.unresolved",
        "listing.active",
        "probate.opened",
        "tax.delinquent"
      ],
      "rows": {
        "size_1": {
          "tried": 15,
          "valid": 9,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 6
          },
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation"
            ],
            [
              "AL_loose:heirship.unresolved"
            ],
            [
              "AL_default:heirship.unresolved"
            ]
          ]
        },
        "size_2": {
          "tried": 90,
          "valid": 82,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 8
          },
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "AL_loose:deed.recorded_event"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "AL_default:deed.recorded_event"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "NOT_PL:deed.recorded_event"
            ]
          ]
        },
        "size_3": {
          "tried": 276,
          "valid": 276,
          "failed_checks": {},
          "valid_examples": [
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "AL_loose:deed.recorded_event",
              "AL_loose:heirship.unresolved"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "AL_loose:deed.recorded_event",
              "AL_default:heirship.unresolved"
            ],
            [
              "PL_loose:code.violation",
              "AL_loose:deed.recorded_event",
              "NOT_PL:heirship.unresolved"
            ]
          ]
        }
      },
      "triple_rescue": {
        "found": false,
        "triple": null
      }
    },
    "blocked_heavy": {
      "n_satisfied_leaves": 6,
      "signals_with_satisfied_leaf": [
        "death.verified",
        "deed.recorded_event",
        "listing.active"
      ],
      "rows": {
        "size_1": {
          "tried": 6,
          "valid": 0,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 6
          },
          "valid_examples": []
        },
        "size_2": {
          "tried": 12,
          "valid": 0,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 12
          },
          "valid_examples": []
        },
        "size_3": {
          "tried": 8,
          "valid": 0,
          "failed_checks": {
            "source_feasibility": 8
          },
          "valid_examples": []
        }
      },
      "triple_rescue": {
        "found": false,
        "triple": null
      }
    },
    "seconds": 66.5,
    "note": "exhaustive singles, pairs and triples of satisfied leaves (distinct signals, all satisfied leaf forms) through the real compose() + validate(); a rescue is a valid triple on a timeline where zero singles and zero pairs validate"
  },
  "density_closure": {
    "results": {
      "all_or_nothing": {
        "trials": 20,
        "exists_trials": 20,
        "match_fraction": 1.0
      },
      "block_correlated": {
        "trials": 20,
        "exists_trials": 20,
        "match_fraction": 1.0
      }
    },
    "seconds": 1.18,
    "note": "existence under perfectly correlated evidence; complementarity holds per signal whatever the joint law"
  },
  "angles_considered": {
    "(a)_different_defeater_model": {
      "verdict": "closed, not attempted",
      "ingredient_deleting_defeaters": "no such mechanism exists in the codebase: SignalClause.defeater is the only defeater, it attaches to a signal clause, and ingredients are producer sets for source feasibility, never logic operands; inventing an ingredient defeater would be synthetic, not a re-verification of the repo",
      "different_density_law": "closed by experiment 4: per-signal complementarity (plain leaf SAT when PRESENT, NOT(defeater) SAT otherwise, in every timeline state including CONFLICTED and below-floor) is density-independent, so any joint law, including perfect correlation, still yields always-YES existence"
    },
    "(b)_deeper_wider_fragment": {
      "verdict": "attempted (this round)",
      "composition_depth_k_gt_3": "closed by proof Lemma 1 (ALL decomposes into independently evaluated children) and confirmed by the extended brute force, which enumerates composite pool nodes as children of ALL trees; depth adds no new witnesses",
      "all_15_ops": "attempted: experiments 1-2",
      "triple_validity_rescue": "attempted: experiment 3"
    },
    "(c)_different_decision_question": {
      "verdict": "closed except as folded into experiment 3",
      "counting": "counting SATISFIED single nodes is one pool pass (polynomial, trivial); counting distinct valid satisfied recipes has no canonical identity, because compose() builds from requests and duplicate signatures collapse, so the question is ill-posed on this codebase",
      "optimization_largest_satisfied_recipe": "evaluator version is trivial (AND all satisfied nodes); the validity-aware version is exactly the triple-rescue question at small sizes, attempted in experiment 3"
    }
  },
  "total_seconds": 246.62,
  "verdict": "The greedy result extends to five of the six non-composer ops by reduction: every SATISFIED CHANGE, ACCELERATION, PERSISTENCE, COUNT_AT_LEAST or CONVERGENCE node implies SATISFIED plain leaves already in the pool (0 non-CF violations), and the extended brute force agrees with greedy 44 of 44 with those five ops in the pool. CONTRADICTION_FREE is the exception: the zero-arg node is SATISFIED on every timeline including the empty one (2674 reduction violations, all CF), so admitting it makes existence in the extended fragment trivially always YES, the same degeneracy as defeaters, for a different reason. No triple validates where singles and pairs fail (rescue found: False); the single-plus-pairs witness search is sufficient on every timeline tested. Nothing here separates or collapses P and NP, and none is claimed."
}