Three seeds, one channel, no agreement: the torelon mass moves more across tau than across chains. The channel is overturned. Nothing solved.
Yang-Mills theory is the quantum theory of the strong force: a gauge field with SU(2) symmetry here, living on spacetime, with a mass gap meaning the lightest particle has strictly positive mass. The Clay problem asks for a rigorous construction of quantum Yang-Mills theory on R4 with a compact simple gauge group, and a proof that it has a mass gap Delta > 0. This lab works on a lattice, where the theory is a finite statistical system that a computer can sample, and measures masses that would become the gap in the continuum limit. The lattice is 84, small, and the continuum limit is an extrapolation, not a measurement. The extrapolation failed, twice, and this page says exactly how.
Method: SU(2) lattice gauge theory on an 84 lattice, Metropolis updates with checkerboard even/odd sweeps, random SU(2) rotation near identity with eps 0.35, cold start, 400 thermalization sweeps and 1500 measurement sweeps per run. Operators: APE smearing of spatial links, alpha 0.5, levels 0, 2, and 4 steps, with a variational GEVP over the three levels, C(1)v = lambda C(0)v, for the 0++ ground-state mass. The torelon is a flux tube winding around the periodic spatial direction; its mass is read from the effective mass at time separation tau, with tau = 1 the picked value. The string tension comes from Creutz ratios chi(2,2).
| Round | What ran | Torelon, beta 2.5 | Torelon, beta 2.6 | Continuum intercept |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (Nov 20) | Beta 2.2 and 2.4 | no torelon run | no torelon run | two spacings only, no extrapolation |
| 2 (Nov 20) | Beta 2.3 added | no torelon run | no torelon run | +3.473 +/- 1.506 (three points; slope 0.011 +/- 5.486) |
| 3 (Nov 20) | Beta 2.5, seed 1 | 1.2798 +/- 0.0822 | no run | +1.634 +/- 0.820 (four points) |
| 4 (Nov 20) | APE smearing and variational GEVP introduced | no new beta point | no new beta point | no new fit |
| 5 (Nov 21) | Beta 2.6, seed 1 | 1.2798 (seed 1) | 1.6084 +/- 0.1611 | +2.4230 +/- 0.7393 (five points) |
| 6 (Nov 21) | Seed 2, both betas | 0.8899 +/- 0.0441 | 1.1931 +/- 0.1059 | -0.2083 +/- 0.6426 (seed 2) |
| 7 (Nov 21) | Seed 3, both betas, plus estimator test | 1.0795 +/- 0.0681 | 1.2675 +/- 0.0524 | +2.1201 +/- 0.5256 (three-seed mean, diagnostic only) |
At beta 2.5 the three seeds give torelon masses 1.2798, 0.8899, and 1.0795, a spread of 0.390. No pair agrees within combined errors. At beta 2.6 they give 1.6084, 1.1931, and 1.2675, a spread of 0.415. Only seeds 2 and 3 agree there.
yang_mills_r6.json and
yang_mills_r7.json.| Torelon mass | Seed 1 | Seed 2 | Seed 3 | Spread |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beta 2.5 | 1.2798 +/- 0.0822 | 0.8899 +/- 0.0441 | 1.0795 +/- 0.0681 | 0.390 |
| Beta 2.6 | 1.6084 +/- 0.1611 | 1.1931 +/- 0.1059 | 1.2675 +/- 0.0524 | 0.415 |
| GEVP 0++ ground-state mass | Seed 1 | Seed 2 | Seed 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beta 2.5 | no GEVP (round 3 predates it) | 1.6263 +/- 0.1034 | 1.3555 +/- 0.1034 |
| Beta 2.6 | 1.3318 +/- 0.0986 | 1.6030 +/- 0.1343 | 1.6591 +/- 0.1600 |
The basic observables are stable across seeds. The plaquette at beta 2.5 reads 0.6531, 0.6529, and 0.6537 across the three seeds; at beta 2.6 it reads 0.6705, 0.6702, and 0.6701. The string tension chi(2,2) at beta 2.5 reads 0.2071, 0.2092, and 0.2078; at beta 2.6 it reads 0.1847, 0.1856, and 0.1876. The torelon spread is hundreds of times the plaquette spread. The chains agree on the easy quantities and disagree on the one that matters.
Round 7 asked whether the disagreement is statistics (different chains) or the estimator itself. Within a single chain, the torelon mass moves across tau far more than it moves across chains at fixed tau. At beta 2.5 the within-seed tau spread reaches 2.395, against a cross-seed spread of 0.390 at the picked tau = 1. At beta 2.6 it is 2.100 against 0.415. The estimator problem is about 5 to 6 times the statistics problem. Seed 1 at beta 2.5 shows it directly: tau 0 gives 2.747, tau 1 gives 1.280, tau 2 gives 0.687. There is no stable plateau. The plateau choice, not the chain, drives the discrepancy.
yang_mills_r7.json (estimator_test).| Torelon mass by tau | tau 0 | tau 1 (picked) | tau 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beta 2.5, seed 1 | 2.747 | 1.280 | 0.687 |
| Beta 2.5, seed 2 | 2.611 | 0.890 | 0.215 |
| Beta 2.5, seed 3 | 2.643 | 1.079 | 0.702 |
| Beta 2.6, seed 1 | 2.789 | 1.608 | 0.722 |
| Beta 2.6, seed 2 | 2.597 | 1.193 | 0.498 |
| Beta 2.6, seed 3 | 2.634 | 1.268 | 0.941 |
The five-point continuum extrapolation was built on seed 1 alone: beta 2.2 to 2.6, torelon mass over sqrt(sigma) against sigma a2, weighted linear fit, intercept +2.4230 +/- 0.7393. Seed 2 gives -0.2083 +/- 0.6426. The two intercepts disagree by 2.63, against combined errors of about 0.98. The extrapolation is overturned (rcpt_0061). A three-seed mean fit gives +2.1201 +/- 0.5256 with chi2 55.35 on 3 degrees of freedom; it is reported as a diagnostic only, not a continuum claim, and no extrapolation is attempted from it. OVERTURNED STANDS (rcpt_0064).
yang_mills_r5.json, yang_mills_r6.json, and
yang_mills_r7.json.| Continuum fit, torelon | Intercept | Slope | chi2 / dof |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seed 1 (round 5) | +2.4230 +/- 0.7393 | 3.2364 +/- 3.2126 | 7.60 / 3 |
| Seed 2 (round 6) | -0.2083 +/- 0.6426 | 11.4401 +/- 2.9630 | 29.71 / 3 |
| Three-seed mean (round 7, diagnostic only) | +2.1201 +/- 0.5256 | 1.9693 +/- 2.5434 | 55.35 / 3 |
Receipt chain: 66 receipts, chain valid, head
bdebd1e7d93dd108bffe0ba01d499e603db81a8c17027bb0aad36a70f73dacdd
(verification receipt rcpt_0066). Yang-Mills receipts:
| Receipt | What it covers |
|---|---|
| rcpt_0061 | Round 6: second seed at beta 2.5 and 2.6; torelon extrapolation OVERTURNED |
| rcpt_0062 | Round 6 chain verification |
| rcpt_0064 | Round 7: third seed at beta 2.5 and 2.6, estimator test; OVERTURNED STANDS |
| rcpt_0066 | Round 7 chain verification; chain head bdebd1e7 |
Data files: data/yang_mills_r6.json (SHA-256
41ffee8393f21b33bc5e1b43cd29fe5d0fa803ae3e4190033323007339ad5cf2),
yang_mills_r7.json (SHA-256
9abc2cfe61a98b2810988dd1928d049544388b7d077c665f48cf799feaf194c1). Earlier
rounds: yang_mills.json, yang_mills_r2.json,
yang_mills_r3.json, yang_mills_r4.json,
yang_mills_r5.json.
A different operator or a larger volume, not more torelon seeds. The GEVP 0++ ground-state mass is the natural next channel, but it also disagrees across seeds, so it needs the same estimator scrutiny first. A larger volume (124 or 164) is the other move.
We simulated the strong force on a tiny 8 by 8 by 8 by 8 grid and tried to measure the mass of the lightest particle it can make. Three runs with different random starting points gave three different answers, and the way we read the answer off the data moved it more than the runs differed from each other. So the measuring stick is broken, not just noisy, and we threw it out instead of averaging the answers and pretending they agreed.
No mass gap measurement, no continuum value, no usable channel. We did not prove the gap is zero, and we did not prove it is positive. We proved one way of measuring it does not work.